Open Thread – Tues 14 Feb 2023

Jacob Blessing the Sons of Joseph, Rembrandt, 1656

Notify of

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Salvatore, Understaffed & Overworked Martyr to Govt Covid Stupidity

Speedbox says: February 17, 2023 at 6:19 pm
The obvious answer is you get what you pay for. Yes, other means of telling the time abound but a good quality utility or diving watch can last decades and withstand all manner of rough treatment. The thing most owners don’t recognise is that utility and diving watches need to be serviced every 5-10 years to maintain seals and replace internal lubricants. Do that and the watch will probably outlast its owner.

Hehe, I’ll take this from the top:

1) RBA governor Philip Lowe can & should use whatever style & price of watch he wants. It is a free country, & if he wants to spend $20,000 bucks to achieve the same result as someone whose watch cost $1.69 on ebay, then who are we to stand in his way?
Likewise who the heck do the j’ismist caste or the Anal govt think they are to make any comment?
The man is paid a salary & merits of that salary aside, he’s harming nobody if he spends way more of that salary than he needs to on a fancy replica of a $2 Seiko.

The money is going to craftsmen, entrepreneurs, & is keeping the wheels of the economy greased, some may say Lowe spending his money on precise timepieces is doing more for the economy than anything he’s ever done at the RBA – I cannot comment on that, it is not for me to say.

2) What RBA governor Philip Lowe should not do is bow to the mob & start using a less expensive watch, one that is say 1/1000 the value of the one he used until yesterday.

Bow to the mob & you’re finished, in every way.

(None of the above is to be taken as commentary on his fitness or suitability as an RBA board member.)

February 17, 2023 8:48 pm

Bow to the mob & you’re finished, in every way.

Absolutely true. Should have done the exact opposite. Wore something even more expensive. “My work watch is being serviced…..”

Zulu Kilo Two Alpha
Zulu Kilo Two Alpha
February 17, 2023 8:48 pm

Outback remains to be tested for murdered backpacker Peter Falconio
John Silvester
By John Silvester
February 17, 2023 — 4.00pm

Human remains found in the outback near Alice Springs will be tested to see if they are from Peter Falconio, the British backpacker murdered in 2001.

Northern Territory police remain tight-lipped on the find because the identity of the remains is yet to be established.

Multiple sources have confirmed to The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald that the bones have been discovered and that they will be cross-checked against the Falconio case because of their age and location.

The remains were found this week in a location consistent with an area where Falconio’s body was suspected to have been dumped, within a few hundred kilometres of where he was shot.

Forensic experts will use DNA and dental records to establish an identity.

The man convicted of the murder, Bradley John Murdoch, has refused to say where he left the body.

Northern Territory Police have initiated multiple searches over the years for Falconio’s body, and have always remained hopeful of finding his remains. Several discoveries – in 2003, 2004 and 2007 – were not linked to Falconio.

“We have been down this track before so we are not jumping to any conclusions,” a Territory detective said.

Falconio, 28, was driving with his girlfriend Joanne Lees along the Stuart Highway north of Alice Springs on July 14, 2001, when Murdoch drove up from behind and motioned for them to pull over, indicating their vehicle may have a mechanical problem.

Lees told police that when the men went to check the car she heard a shot and was then tied up by Murdoch. She managed to escape and hid for five hours while Murdoch hunted her. She flagged down a passing truck to escape.

February 17, 2023 8:51 pm

Having a beer and steak in Singapore Airport before I return to the land of minimal beer and minimal steak.

Knackered after yesterday, on the tools, trying to get the level alarms set right. Up and down the tank ladders a 100 times.

Ed Case
Ed Case
February 17, 2023 8:57 pm

Is it correct that the train cars were NOT leaking after the derailment and could have been taken to some deserted area.
Why were they cut open and set ablaze?

Anyone know?
Watch lovers?

February 17, 2023 9:01 pm

Salvatore, Understaffed & Overworked Martyr to Govt Covid Stupidity says:
February 17, 2023 at 8:41 pm

What RBA governor Philip Lowe should not do is bow to the mob & start using a less expensive watch, one that is say 1/1000 the value of the one he used until yesterday. Bow to the mob & you’re finished, in every way.


February 17, 2023 9:03 pm

rickw says:
February 17, 2023 at 8:51 pm

I haven’t been through Changi for ages. Do they still have the rooftop pool?

February 17, 2023 9:06 pm

Is it correct that the train cars were NOT leaking after the derailment and could have been taken to some deserted area.
Why were they cut open and set ablaze?

I only know a bit about road tankers. A key design requirement is that potential for a leak after an accident is minimised. Top fittings need to be mounted within a combing to protect them from being sheared off, and they need to be liquid tight. All bottom fittings need to be fitted with foot valves mounted internal to the tank so that external fittings can be sheared off without causing a leak. I can’t see why the same sorts of approaches wouldn’t be applied to rail cars. Thus a low speed derailment shouldn’t result in any leakage of product.

Robert Sewell
February 17, 2023 9:11 pm

Dover Beach.

Incredible footage.

No, standard fare for Germany in 1932 and Europe 2023.
We’re supposed to be looking for a ‘strong man’ government to sort the mess out – but we’re failing to see that it’s the ‘strong men’ doing this.
Arm the people and see this shit stop.

H B Bear
H B Bear
February 17, 2023 9:13 pm

Why is there a waiting list? Most of the big watch brands have got minimal inventory on display in airports?

Not really a waiting list. I don’t think the Authorized Dealers even know what or when they are going to get from the manufacturer. Apparently you haven’t been able to get a steel Rolex for months (not that I’ve tied). The ADs just keep taking whatever they are sent hoping they get something they can move it on. If you are in a real hurry you pay over list from somebody flipping for profit meanwhile the ADs move unloved stuff like solid gold or dual metal onto grey market dealers to discount. All pretty opaque but it’s been done like that forever.

February 17, 2023 9:16 pm

If anyone is criticising Philip Lowe and the RBA, you ought to look at this chart.

To those who didn’t study economics or finance, M0 is CASH. This is why asset prices have gone APESHIT since COVID-19.

Set to either 5 years or max, as a line probably.

(A shame we can post pics here like :groans: … 4chan).

Barking Toad
Barking Toad
February 17, 2023 9:17 pm

A year after he retired from acting because of growing cognitive difficulties, Bruce Willis’ family reveal his condition has progressed.


He should stand for POTUS now he has dementia.

H B Bear
H B Bear
February 17, 2023 9:18 pm

Go hard and go early.

February 17, 2023 9:19 pm

St John of God Subiaco Hospital acting chief executive Jenny Brenton said a ‘serious incident’ which resulted in an ‘adverse outcome for a patient’.

No shit, Sherlock.

Salvatore, Understaffed & Overworked Martyr to Govt Covid Stupidity

The most recent series of “Blue Bloods” (a cop show set in New York city, starring Tom Selleck & Donnie Wahlberg) has an episode themed on the expensive men’s wristwatch industry.
Others may be able to comment on the accuracy/authenticity of the theme.

Robert Sewell
February 17, 2023 9:25 pm
I liked the bit from the article:

A bystander heckled Sam Brinton as he walked through the courthouse.
“Did you steal any luggage today?” a man shouted. “What are you wearing?”
Brinton ignored the reporters and briskly walked away.

I thought ‘briskly walked away’ was rather cute.

February 17, 2023 9:31 pm

Sturgeon looks as ugly as her politics. What a slag.

Barking Toad
Barking Toad
February 17, 2023 9:42 pm

Sturgeon should be on the float with Tennis Albo.

Them Arden should jump on too. And that Wong chap.

They can all be sodomized.

Barking Toad
Barking Toad
February 17, 2023 9:46 pm

Or is Arden they? I can’t keep up.

February 17, 2023 9:47 pm

“St John of God Subiaco Hospital acting chief executive Jenny Brenton said a ‘serious incident’ which resulted in an ‘adverse outcome for a patient’.”

Oxygen leak followed by a whole lot of shit spontaneously combusting? Most probably including surgical cloth covering the patient?

February 17, 2023 9:50 pm

Sturgeon looks as ugly as her politics. What a slag.

If you Google Scottish Minga, you get sturgeon images. No shit.

Robert Sewell
February 17, 2023 9:51 pm

10 minutes of cat videos.
They don’t give a damn about the Money Supply.

Knuckle Dragger
Knuckle Dragger
February 17, 2023 9:53 pm

Falconio’s remains.

Maybe. Or it may be one of the dozens of people who for one reason or another have wandered off into the central Australian desert and died in the last twenty years.

I note the conspicuous absence of a ‘jelly man’ in the reporting to date.

Robert Sewell
February 17, 2023 9:54 pm


Oxygen leak followed by a whole lot of shit spontaneously combusting? Most probably including surgical cloth covering the patient?

A whole lot of shit has to go wrong before this happens.
Talk about bad luck…

Knuckle Dragger
Knuckle Dragger
February 17, 2023 9:54 pm

263, Straya made.

About 100 more than I thought they would, I must say.

February 17, 2023 9:55 pm

To those who didn’t study economics or finance, M0 is CASH. This is why asset prices have gone APESHIT since COVID-19.

Set to either 5 years or max, as a line probably.

That’s a quite alarming chart.

February 17, 2023 9:59 pm

Full comic here, you guffy soutpiel pudden ringos.

Stervin – The Scottish Manga

February 17, 2023 10:03 pm

Lathe of the week! Make an offer on a couple of tons of Dean Smith and Grace:

Knuckle Dragger
Knuckle Dragger
February 17, 2023 10:04 pm

Jesus Christ Dot.

That’s brilliant. I just thought the ex-fattie was going to tell the bloke to piss off.

February 17, 2023 10:04 pm

Heard a pom.
Went back to the UK for the first time in 4 years.
Everyone’s paying 3 4 thousand for electricity £7 for a pint, covid’s changed everyone, not friendly any more.
Here three pints for €10 and there is sun, so much sun.
Carnival starts today and Valletta is packed.
Now sitting near a very chatty expatriate from Melbourne.

Sancho Panzer
Sancho Panzer
February 17, 2023 10:06 pm

Now sitting near a very chatty expatriate from Melbourne.

Is he stuffing his face with pastizzi?

February 17, 2023 10:08 pm

KD, another man of culture.

This is why manga is good. It isn’t PC. Even if it is made by a bunch of skivvie porridge wogs.

Zulu Kilo Two Alpha
Zulu Kilo Two Alpha
February 17, 2023 10:10 pm

Letter arrives 105 years after being posted
Jack Blackburn, History Correspondent
Thursday February 16 2023, 5.40pm GMT, The Times
Royal Mail

How late has your post been recently? A few days? Weeks? Maybe a month? Strike action may be causing significant delays at present, but they are nothing compared to the time taken for one letter to make it from Bath to Crystal Palace which has finally arrived 105 years after it was posted.

It was originally sent by a Christabel Mennell, who seemed to be racked by guilt and wished to make amends with her friend, Katie Marsh. Mennell was on holiday at the time and therefore posted the letter from a house in Bath in February 1916. Sadly, Katie would never receive it.

It finally fell through the letter box of 18 Hamlet Road in 2021, where it was picked up by the present resident, Finlay Glen, 27, a theatre director.
The contents of the letter, sent by a Christabel Mennell, were aimed at making amends with her friend, Katie Marsh

Confronted with a stamp bearing the image of George V, which cost a penny in 1916, Glen swiftly realised that the Bath postmark did not refer to February 6, 2016.

“We were obviously pretty surprised and mystified as to how it could have been sat around for more than 100 years,” Glen told the BBC.

Glen’s mystification was shared by the Royal Mail. “Incidents like this happen very occasionally,” a spokesperson said, “and we are uncertain what happened in this instance.”

The letter’s story has come to light after Glen kept it in a drawer for two years. Despite the legal difficulties of opening someone else’s mail, he felt that a 105-year-old letter was “fair game”.

Its contents seem to reveal an attempt to pour oil on the waters between two friends. Mennell, who was the daughter of a wealthy local tea merchant, writes on headed paper, where her presumably usual address of 31 Park Hill Rise, Croydon, is crossed out.

She writes to Marsh, who, perhaps ironically given this story, was the wife of a local stamp magnate who was often called as an expert witness at stamp fraud trials.

Mennell says she is “quite ashamed of myself after saying what I did”, and spends much of the letter complaining about a terrible cold she is suffering from.

The pair are thought to be extremely middle class, and Stephen Oxford, a local historian, has said that they reflected the changing demographics of the area.

“Crystal Palace generated a huge influx of very wealthy people and so to find out about someone who moved to the area for possibly that very reason is absolutely fascinating,” he said.

On today’s roads, the distance between Bath and southeast London is roughly 121 miles, meaning that the letter travelled at an average speed of 1.15 miles a year. A tortoise walking for eight hours a day would have covered that distance in just over 50 days.

Glen hopes that the letter’s journey is not quite over yet. “It’s an amazing piece of their family history that has turned up,” he said. “If they want to, they can come round.”

Knuckle Dragger
Knuckle Dragger
February 17, 2023 10:10 pm

‘Now sitting near a very chatty expatriate from Melbourne.’

If it’s a midget with long greying hair and a goatee, it’s Alex Vella the Rebels bikie chief who got locked out of Straya some years back.

If he asks, don’t bring back anything in your baggage for him.

February 17, 2023 10:14 pm

Talk about upset! An opportunity to expand my Cazeneuve lathe collection and I’m not in Mongistan:

February 17, 2023 10:16 pm

Wests Tigers (Balmain) fans

New club song. On the quest to win minor premiers or the grand final again.

February 17, 2023 10:18 pm

Stervin – The Scottish Manga

That was something else!!

February 17, 2023 10:40 pm

If it’s a midget with long greying hair and a goatee, it’s Alex Vella the Rebels bikie chief who got locked out of Straya some years back.

Might have been, if so he’s changed a bit, got the impression this gentleman might have been very fond of throw cushions

Colonel Crispin Berka
Colonel Crispin Berka
February 17, 2023 10:40 pm

Dot says: February 17, 2023 at 9:16 pm

They tripled the Australian money supply in 14 months.
So we haven’t seen even half of the CPI increase coming down the lendertubes?

Hyperinflationary spiral??

February 17, 2023 10:55 pm

Hyperinflationary spiral??

Mongstralia @ work.

It seems to me that a massive number of otherwise untested bureaucrats, in a number fields, had their moment in the sun and managed to almost universally completely f’ck things.

February 17, 2023 10:55 pm

Janet A’s article of Senator Reynolds interview is a ripper.

Penny Wong and Katy Gallagher don’t come out looking very good but then their performance throughput the saga has been a disgrace.

Kimberly Kitching warned Reynolds the hit job was coming.

What is despicable about what happened is that since the case was pending trial she could not really speak out.

I believe Reynolds version and can well understand why she made her comment about Higgins.

Zulu Kilo Two Alpha
Zulu Kilo Two Alpha
February 17, 2023 11:01 pm

From the Oz – I’ve posted the first installment.

Doubts, devastation and a designer coat: the story you haven’t heard

When Brittany Higgins walked out of Parliament House on March 23, 2019, she was captured on CCTV wearing a Carla Zampatti jacket. That coat defines the gaping divide between the public’s perception of the Higgins saga and what others knew.
By Janet Albrechtsen

When Brittany Higgins walked out of Parliament House at 10.01am on Saturday, March 23, 2019, she was captured on CCTV wearing a black and white Carla Zampatti jacket.

“I borrowed a jacket from the goodwill box,” Higgins told police just over a week later, on April 1.

The Zampatti coat – where it came from, let alone what happened to it – is a small detail in a very big story. Yet it defines the gaping, perplexing divide between the public’s perception of the Higgins saga and what others knew. The jacket is emblematic of the doubts and disagreements about that night and what happened after.
Read Next

While the young staffer would repeat the claim that she took a jacket from a goodwill box in Linda Reynolds’ ministerial suite in her testimony in the ACT Supreme Court last October during the rape trial of Bruce Lehrmann, members of Reynolds’ office have told The Weekend Australian that there was no goodwill bin or box or pile of clothes for charity in Reynolds’ ministerial suite.

There was just a wardrobe full of the minister’s jackets. Including the Zampatti that Higgins took, after waking up in her boss’s office following a night drinking at The Dock bar in Canberra with colleagues and a Bumble date, before going to a nightclub for more drinks with Lehrmann and two other staffers.

Away from the court case that followed after Higgins alleged Lehrmann raped her in the ministerial suite, after the media stories, the questions in parliament, the poring over details, all of which moulded public opinion, there was another story the public never heard. And this story might not quite match what the public thought they knew.
Linda Reynolds ‘Why I’m speaking now’
Former Defence Minister Linda Reynolds has broken her silence about the alleged rape of Brittany Higgins, the…

Higgins has used the media to tell her story many times. Lehrmann told his story too, during a three-hour recorded police interview that was played in court last year. The trial, as we know, was aborted last October after a jury member went rogue. The Director of Public Prosecutions chose not to proceed with a second trial. Lehrmann has, all along, maintained his innocence. And many untold stories remain just that.

With this week marking the two-year anniversary of the explosive interview with Higgins by Lisa Wilkinson on The Project, Reynolds wants to set the record straight. Once and for all time, she says.

Reynolds spoke with The Weekend Australian last weekend, over more than four hours. As she sat down, she said she would answer every question. No holds barred. She is a no-nonsense woman. There is not a hint of self-pity. Which is remarkable given that Reynolds has been portrayed as a central villain in the Higgins story, a political conspirator who hid the rape of her staffer prior to the 2019 federal election.

At the outset, Reynolds tells me she respects Higgins’ right to tell her story. “I respected her agency and it was her to story to tell. Just because it didn’t match with my recollection of events and my story, it doesn’t invalidate her right to tell her story, which she has,” Reynolds says.

“But it didn’t accord with my recollection of what had happened two years ago.”

Reynolds was not able to tell her story during the criminal trial last year; prosecutor Shane Drumgold treated her as a hostile witness during the trial. Reynolds was prevented from telling her story during the civil claim where Higgins made serious allegations against her former boss and also against Reynolds’ chief of staff, Fiona Brown; Labor Attorney-General Mark Dreyfus used his powers to muzzle Reynolds, instructing her not to attend the mediation in return for the commonwealth paying her legal fees.

Now, Reynolds is speaking up.

More to follow, Over.

Barking Toad
Barking Toad
February 17, 2023 11:02 pm

Has anyone posted Janet A’s piece on here? If so I missed it but happy to scroll back.

If not would appreciate if it can be posted. Cheers.

Zulu Kilo Two Alpha
Zulu Kilo Two Alpha
February 17, 2023 11:06 pm

More, from the article in the Oz.

‘A bomb went off in my head’

“It’s been the hardest two years of my life, without question,” she says, sitting on a sofa across from her partner of nine years, Robert Reid.

Reynolds recounts watching the Project interview in her office with her staff. “It was just like a bomb went off in my head. It was like, what is, what is Lisa saying? What is this conversation about me and about Fiona?” Reynolds says. “Because almost everything that was said did not accord with my recollection of what had happened two years previously.

“I actually couldn’t believe what I was hearing and seeing. It was just such a shock. Being accused of covering up the rape of a young woman for political purposes. It was like a stake through my heart.

“It hurt,” she says, quietly.

That pain is still not far from the surface. The 57-year-old former defence minister recalls how Labor senators “just kept at me asking me questions day after day, essentially saying that I covered up the rape of a young woman. And that was one of the most distressing and confronting things in your workplace, having your colleagues not only in your workplace, but in front of the entire nation, accusing you day after day of covering up the rape of a woman.”

Labor senators Penny Wong and Katy Gallagher led the charge, using a pincer movement in the days and weeks that followed the Project interview. Between them they asked Reynolds eight questions in the Senate on February 15, 2019, the night the Project interview aired. With no clue about what was about to explode that night, Reynolds didn’t have immediate access to notes or files. The next day, February 16, another six questions were fired at Reynolds; the next day, another nine.

Reynolds gave a statement in the Senate on February 18, setting out how, during a meeting with Higgins, she offered her young staffer full support in whatever course of action she chose. In that statement to her Senate colleagues, Reynolds asked that this very serious issue be dealt with “away from politics”.

Not a chance. Labor senators lined up the next day, posing nine questions to her, then a dozen more the following day.

Reynolds maintained then what she maintains now: she did the right thing, supporting Higgins, encouraging her to speak with AFP officers in Parliament House and to seek counselling if that’s what she wanted. “Parliament is the last place, and the media is the last place that these matters should ever be discussed,” she says to me. “Having supported family members and friends, and a colleague in the parliament as well, a staffer in previous years … I understood the concept of agency from those personal experiences. Anything relating to sexual assault … these are not matters that should be played out in public.”

‘The incident’

Reynolds is keen to tell her story about what happened during the first few days after Higgins and Lehrmann entered her ministerial suite in the early hours of Saturday, March 23, 2019. This was, she says, a very serious security breach. In her police statement it is described as “the incident”.

Reynolds is a stickler for rules, proper processes, and, working in the defence portfolio, she explains how highly sensitive matters in this area demand a higher standard.

“When you work in a ministerial office, either as a minister or the trusted staff, you are privileged to great information, and in the defence portfolio highly sensitive information. And I think as every Australian would expect, that comes with a higher standard of conduct and behaviour and security is No.1. So that was just a huge security breach.”

She says entering her ministerial suite unauthorised, in the early hours of Saturday night, as Higgins and Lehrmann had done, was “a sackable offence”. “It doesn’t get much worse than that.”

As Reynolds told police, the Department of Parliamentary Ser­vices was notified of the unauthorised entry by the two drunk staffers by security guards. The Department of Finance – effectively the HR department of parliament – was notified and told Reynolds’ chief of staff, Brown, about the security breach and provided advice on how to appropriately discipline staff about the unauthorised after-hours access to the minister’s suite.

That same day, Tuesday, March 26, Brown had separate meetings with Lehrmann, first, and then with Higgins about the security breach.

As Brown said in her evidence in court last year, Lehrmann was asked to hand in his security pass. This was his second serious security breach. His employment was terminated in the following days.

Brown met Higgins next to ask for her account of entering the minister’s office after-hours and unauthorised. The 24-year-old staffer was not dismissed but instead was reminded of her responsibilities under the code of conduct, which she had not previously signed.

Reynolds says she was told by Brown that during this first meeting Higgins said she was drunk and that she was responsible for her actions. Brown and Reynolds took that at face value.

I ask Reynolds what the prime minister’s office was told at that time. “This is sort of one of the great myths,” she says, “… that I and my chief of staff actually had conversations back then with the prime minister’s office about an allegation of rape. It wasn’t, it was actually in relation to Bruce (Lehrmann) because you talked to the prime minister’s office – they do ministerial staffing. And then also to the Department of Finance and the special minister of state (Alex Hawke) because they’re the HR department for government ministers. Fiona talked to both, quite rightly, got detailed advice in her usual meticulous way.”

Brown met Higgins again, on Thursday, March 28. Brown gave evidence during the trial that as Higgins left this meeting, Higgins turned to say: “I remember that he was on top of me.” When Brown responded in dismay, asking Higgins whether something happened that she didn’t want to have happen, Brown told the court that Higgins shook her head. The young staffer said her dad was coming to Canberra. Brown said in court she told Higgins: “Oh, okay, well, that’s good. Okay, well, we are here if you want to do anything, we are here. And she seemed composed.”

Reynolds had been in Brisbane on Tuesday, when Brown first met with Higgins. The minister returned to Canberra that evening, and travelled to Perth on Wednesday night. She was in constant conversation with Brown about her meetings with Higgins.

Reynolds describes her conversations with Brown about Higgins: “In the first meeting she’s (Higgins) remorseful, embarrassed. Apologising. It’s the second meeting where she starts to get more upset. Fiona had done all the right things. Fiona did absolutely everything that she was advised to do, but she was also advised about agency.”

Reynolds is referring to an email that Brown received at 6.05pm on March 29, 2019, from a Department of Finance official that summarised the actions and support offered by Brown to Higgins during their meetings and phone conversations. It included advising Higgins about counselling services, advising Higgins that it was her choice to make a complaint, and that she would be supported at any stage that she decided to pursue a matter with police.

Zulu Kilo Two Alpha
Zulu Kilo Two Alpha
February 17, 2023 11:11 pm

More, from the article in the Oz.

In that same email to Brown, the department confirms that “the steps you have taken are appropriate” and then says: “Ultimately any decision as to whether to lodge a police report or pursue any other form of complaint relating to this matter would be a personal choice of the person involved. I note the 1800Respect website recommends the person should have ‘as much control as possible over what to do next’ and that a person ‘may decide not to report to police, or to have a medical or examination … This is their choice and must be respected’. For a referral to be made on her behalf, or without her consent or against her wishes could be harmful to her.”

Reynolds wanted to check on Higgins when she was back in the office on Monday; Brown and Reynolds were concerned that something sexual had happened.

“I came back on the Monday (April 1) and she (Higgins) didn’t make an allegation of rape. I tried to be sympathetic, and I did say to her that there’s AFP in the building, they’re probably better to talk to. They’ve got counsellors available and things if you think you need it.

“If Brittany or anybody else hasn’t made an allegation of rape, then you can’t force them to do anything. But you can be there to support, which as you can see from all those actions, she was,” says Reynolds.

Reynolds also relayed in her formal police statement that during this meeting Higgins was “extremely apologetic”, described her actions as “unprofessional” and said to Reynolds that “she didn’t want to lose her job”.

I ask: Did Higgins tell Reynolds that she was raped that night?

“No,” says Reynolds, “there was never any allegation of rape.”

Did she say she was assaulted in some way?

“No,” says Reynolds.

Did Brown tell Reynolds that Higgins mentioned a rape or assault to her? “No,” says Reynolds.

Higgins confirmed this to journalist Samantha Maiden. “I said (to Brown) that he was on top of me. I think for the longest time I was real­ly weird about actually saying it was rape. I don’t know why. I was very delicate about it. I think from our exchange she understood the inference,’’ Higgins told

‘Lying cow’

Reynolds’ usual polite demeanour fell away as news broke about Higgins’ allegations that she and her chief of staff had not supported her. Reynolds would utter those fateful words – “lying cow” – that would later be splashed across the media when it was first reported by this newspaper.

The wink, wink insinuation was that Reynolds questioned the truth of the rape allegation that Higgins made on television that evening. “That was wrong,” says Reynolds. No one can know what happened that night except the two people involved.

Reynolds says she was reacting to allegations, aired in the media the first time, that she and Brown had treated Higgins poorly, that they brought Higgins into Reynolds’ office knowing that Higgins claimed a rape had taken place on the sofa in that office, and was forced to choose between reporting a rape to the police or keeping her job. “It [her outburst] was about the alleged lack of support that Fiona and I offered her.”

Reynolds maintains she did everything she could to support Higgins. Why then did Reynolds pay a sum of money to Higgins after the “lying cow” outburst? She says, after what would unfold in the next few days and weeks, “I just didn’t have the strength to fight it.” Many saw the payment as go-away money given it could not have been defamatory for Reynolds to contest Higgins’ claims that she was unsupported by her and Brown.

Did Reynolds ever imply that Higgins’ job was on the line if she made a police complaint?

“No. Never,” says Reynolds.

In fact, when an election was called just over 10 days later, on April 11, 2019, Reynolds and Brown discussed various options with Higgins: work at campaign headquarters, or campaign with Reynolds in Perth, or work from her home in Brisbane during the campaign.

“She chose to come to Perth and, as far as I knew, I don’t see every one of my staff every day – there were seven or eight staying in Perth for the campaign – she was out campaigning every day. As far as I knew, she was still pursuing the matter with the police,” Reynolds tells me.

There are tweets from Higgins during this period praising Reynolds and a photo of a campaign dinner where Higgins is smiling, seated next to Reynolds, in a white dress.

This photo would become trial evidence to contest Higgins’ claim that after wearing this same dress on the night of the alleged rape, she kept it “under my bed in a plastic bag for a good six months, untouched, uncleaned”.

After the Higgins allegations exploded on the national stage two years ago, Reynolds recounts that she requested a private meeting with Sex Discrimination Commissioner Kate Jenkins on February 23, 2021, to discuss the issue. In late September, Reynolds met Jenkins again for an extended interview for her report that was precipitated by the Higgins scandal. “She (Jenkins) was unable to advise me what more I could have done.”

On the ABC’s Insiders program in March 2021, Jenkins confirmed that a victim-centric approach means respecting the agency of women as to whether they wish to make a police complaint. Jenkins alluded to the “very wicked problem” that ministers face when confronted with these issues.

Reynolds was attacked day in, day out for her handling of this matter, including for not informing prime minister Scott Morrison. But she maintains she was respecting Higgins’ agency.

“Was I going to tell the prime minister? No,” she insists. “If you were a staff member in BHP, if you were thinking about whether you were going to make a complaint, if you were talking to police and counsellors, would you want someone else to tell the CEO? Doing so without their permission is a violation of their agency.”

February 17, 2023 11:14 pm

Good timing Zulu!

Zulu Kilo Two Alpha
Zulu Kilo Two Alpha
February 17, 2023 11:20 pm

‘Everyone has a breaking point’

Reynolds describes how Labor wanted her scalp, and after days and weeks of attacks they found her breaking point.

“One of the bigger issues now, on reflection, two years later, is who do we want to be as senators and as parliamentarians representing the nation? I’ve had to think a lot about that … whether I could physically and mentally stay. Because what this showed me is that even the strongest people have a breaking point and Labor found mine. It was calculated, it was deliberate.

“I tried to be unfailingly polite and answer the questions as much as I could, respecting her (Higgins’) agency, as I said time and time again. But ultimately, it was like crows pecking on the carcass until it’s gone, they just kept at me, every day, they just kept diminishing me.” After giving her statement to the Senate, and becoming emotional during question time, Reynolds broke down after being asked an unrelated question about Home Affairs.

‘I just was sobbing uncontrollably’

Reynolds describes it quietly: “I could hardly speak. I just said I need you to take this on notice. I sat down and one of my colleagues helped me out, Senator (Paul) Scarr. He’s a beautiful man. And then I was out in the anteroom and I just was sobbing uncontrollably and you know, chest pains. I was literally inconsolable.”

This wasn’t performance art. Here was a strong, successful, determined woman – a woman with an important portfolio, the first woman to reach the rank of army brigadier in the Army Reserves, the first female to hold the position of adjutant-general of army, the first female deputy federal director of the Liberal Party – in a state of utter collapse. Far from the public eye.

“Someone had sent a message to Scott (Morrison) and it was towards the end of his question time, but he came straight over,” she recalls. “I went into the whip’s office and (Morrison) sat with me. I don’t know how long it was for. Just the two of us. It still sort of makes me a little emotional, but he was just so wonderful. I was still sobbing and speaking through tears.

“And, you know, I will never forget his kindness.”

The PM’s apology

The day before her breakdown, Morrison had very publicly rebuked Reynolds, describing it as unacceptable that she had not told him or his office about the alleged rape in her office.

Reynolds tells me that Morrison expressed regret to her in private the next day when Reynolds was escorted, in a state of collapse, from the Senate chamber into the Senate anteroom, and then into Dean Smith’s office.

“He was clearly sorry for what had happened to me. And I explained to him why I couldn’t and didn’t tell him, and he understood,” she says.

“While she never said the rape word, we had sort of thought she may have had some concerns, something had happened. But it was never my story to tell anyone.”

I ask why she thinks he apologised to her. “He realised that it was never my position to tell anybody about Brittany Higgins’ story,” Reynolds says.

Though Reynolds says she has “mixed feelings” about how some on her own side treated her during this time, she says she is very grateful to her “guardian angels” – Anne Ruston, Jane Hume and Marise Payne – who supported her and protected her. “They were like lionesses when I couldn’t protect myself from Labor, from the PMO, from the media, and other attack dogs. Those running the prime minister’s office distanced themselves from me in exactly the way that the Higgins camp intended. It was lonely,” she recalls. She says her partner, Robert, saved her life with his love and support.

Reynolds is hazy about the exact day – the days and weeks, she says, ran into each other – when she describes another morning in her office after days of relentless, unfair attacks on her. It was before Senate questions.

“I was in the bathroom. I was on the floor. I was just broken. I was sobbing. I was inconsolable. Anne (Ruston) – my saving angel – bolted in from across the corridor … and she just immediately took charge. I think she contacted Simon Birmingham, the (Senate) leader. It was so bad. I literally cannot remember whether I did actually get up for question time that day or I didn’t. She (Ruston) took charge of my staff and she just made sure that I had a space to calm down.”

‘I could have died’

I ask Reynolds about the extent of the collateral damage done to her, attacked in the Senate, in the media, hung out to dry by her own side. “I could have died,” she says simply.

Reynolds ended up in hospital on the eve of a National Press Club address. She recalls former health minister Greg Hunt telling her after question time: “Linda, you look grey”, and arranging for a doctor to see her. She describes the spasms around her heart, her heart rate spiralling up. “It was just awful.”

She ended up waiting outside Canberra Hospital, but finally saw a cardiologist late that night in his rooms. “I had the most horrific night. I didn’t get any sleep, and I was in pain. Robert, Anne (Ruston) and Jane (Hume) were incredibly worried.”

The following day she was still planning to give her NPC address. She spoke with the specialist who, she says, said “don’t be stupid, just come straight down to the hospital. And I did. And I was admitted.”

Robert Sewell
February 17, 2023 11:22 pm


Many of us here do it – keep a journal/diary/whatever.
Because it can be a lifesaver when someone else tells lies about you.
I got into the habit during the last ten years of my nursing career and am grateful I did because that habit has stuck with me. I wish I’d done it during the 80’s and 90’s.
We may not like it but it is a predatory world out there and the other side don’t play by Queensbury rules. Not any more.

Zulu Kilo Two Alpha
Zulu Kilo Two Alpha
February 17, 2023 11:30 pm

Last installment, from the Oz

‘I feel sorry for Brittany’

Few people outside her inner circle understand that, despite the betrayal, the damage, the emotional and physical toll on her, Reynolds has no residual anger. Unusually, especially for a politician, there is little sign of bitterness or a thirst for revenge. Just setting the record straight will do for Reynolds. Part of that is explaining her feelings for Higgins.

“There are no winners from this,” she says more than once to me.

“I feel very sorry for Brittany Higgins because her personal circumstances should always have been played out in the privacy of the justice system – she was terribly exploited by proponents of the #MeToo movement, by opponents of the government.

“The allegation that she made to Lisa Wilkinson first, and then to the police, was an allegation of rape. It should never have been played out in the Senate. It should never have been played out in the media.

“And it became all about what happened afterwards, not about that night. And that is fundamentally wrong.

“I have no doubt that this was a highly orchestrated political campaign, a political hit job on myself as defence minister, to get my scalp, to hurt Scott Morrison and the government of the day.”

‘What was The Project thinking?’

“They exploited Brittany Higgins and her story,” says Reynolds. “This should only ever have been in the jurisdiction of law enforcement and the judicial system.”

Reynolds says that if there was an allegation of rape in any other workplace, it would be horrifying if it played out in public, let alone right across that workplace.

“I mean, it just wouldn’t happen. It shouldn’t happen. But yet it was OK for politicians and journalists to do it?

“What was The Project thinking? Putting a woman as distressed as Brittany Higgins was on national TV before she’d even talked to the police again. Putting her outside Parliament House in front of thousands of people. I mean, how is that not exploitation?”

‘Dinner + Drinks with Lucy and Malcolm’

The Weekend Australian has seen copies of two pages from Higgins’ 2021 Kikki.K gold spiral-bound diary for the week from March 8 to March 14 – the week before the March4Justice where Higgins would speak.

There are handwritten entries across the two pages. Under Tuesday, March 9, blue handwriting says: “Laura Tingle dinner” and “Katharine Murphy”.

On Monday, March 8, there are notes to the side about “4Corners Porter/Kate” and “J-Bish interview”. Under Wednesday, March 10, there are notes about “4 Corners Chat” and “Lunch w Sam Maiden.” Under Thursday, March 11: “wrote speech for women’s march.” Under Saturday, March 13, there is larger blue handwriting: “Dinner + Drinks with Lucy and Malcolm.” With an arrow in black pointing to “Lisa and Pete dinner”. Under Sunday, March 14, there are notes about: “Fly to CBR”, and “Newspoll ALP 51 Lead” with “51” circled.

Among the many media and political mentions in Higgins’ diary is a notation under March 12 – “AFP visit and more statement”.

There’s nothing wrong with Higgins dining with journalists, with Wilkinson, FitzSimons, and the Turnbulls. It is an insight, though, into the confluence of forces that transformed an untested allegation of rape into an unstoppable juggernaut.

During the trial, an extract from an audio recording was played where Higgins’ boyfriend, David Sharaz, said they wanted the rape allegation to be exposed at the start of the parliamentary sitting week because he had a “friend” on the Labor side – now known to be Finance Minister Katy Gallagher – who would “probe and continue it”.

The trial also revealed that Sharaz, with Higgins’ consent, distributed an extensive information dossier to sections of the media to help them. In the witness box, Higgins described how journalists jockeyed over her story: “It became not even about me or my story, it became about them.”

Reynolds agrees.

“I think it was a terrible abuse of Brittany Higgins’ circumstances. She was clearly, in my mind, exploited for overtly political purposes, by Labor, and also a number of prominent journalists and female advocates who, in the #MeToo zeitgeist, had found their perfect vehicle to elevate the movement but also to bring down a senior minister to hurt the Morrison government.

“This became a political hit job, less about an alleged rape, and almost exclusively about bringing down a cabinet minister, to damage the prime minister and bring down the Morrison government.”

Reynolds has been the subject of so many wicked claims and innuendo, including that her office was steam cleaned as part of a political conspiracy to get rid of evidence of a rape.

“I had no knowledge of or involvement in the decision to clean my office,” she says. Reynolds says the Department of Parliamentary Services arranged a cleaner on Saturday, after hearing of a drunken incident – three days before her office was told about a security breach. She and her office were accused of withholding CCTV footage from Higgins. Also not true. Reynolds says she had not seen the CCTV footage when that claim was first made. It was the property of DPS.

During the trial, Reynolds was accused, in the words of Drumgold, of “coaching” the defence by texting Lehrmann’s lawyer Steve Whybrow SC during his cross-examination of Higgins. This was pure theatre from the DPP. No witness is the property of either defence or prosecution. In any case, Reynolds’ texts were disclosed to Drumgold.

In hindsight, Reynolds says it was a mistake that her partner Robert sat in court before she gave evidence, and for her to ask for transcripts. When she was told this was not appropriate, she accepted that. She says she had never been through a trial. Nothing hung on these misjudgments, yet Drumgold singled her out for criticism when he also rebuked the AFP, after announcing there would be no retrial of Lehrmann.

When we meet, there is a relaxed aura about Reynolds. Her smile is gentle, she laughs easily, though her eyes still give away the pain of the trap that ensnared her. Finally, telling her side, “it’s cathartic”, she says.

We talk about why conservative women are treated so differently by the media, and in politics.

“We are expendable,” she says. “Our story is ignored, diminished, derided. As conservative women and particularly conservative politicians, we’re invisible to the feminist movement. And they really don’t understand us. They don’t want to understand us. We’re expendable. I was expendable. My chief staff was expendable.”

We agree that is for another day.
Janet Albrechtsen

H B Bear
H B Bear
February 18, 2023 12:20 am

Still life in the ol’ Brittany saga yet. Stay tuned …

February 18, 2023 12:06 pm

Reynolds was a rather unsatisfactory Defence Minister, but if she continues to play the Higgins outrage in this masterful way, justice may even be served.
Whoever is coaching her to treat the villians in the conspiracy with such courtesy and respect is a genius.
Her more direct attack on Drummond who is already revealed as dodgy, is equally clever.
I hope she keeps her nerve and sues them until their skin bubbles.
A perfect, but impossible outcome would be for CCP Wong to be publically called to account.

1 8 9 10
  1. No toons again today as my laptop internet (via iPhone hotspot) refuses to connect and my Officeworks tech guru is…

  2. Knuckle Dragger April 22, 2024 8:58 pm English is the International languageOf airline pilots. You do need to get out…

  3. As was pointed out above. They are all all using whitey magic tools to carry on their traditional hunting. Ditch…

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x