Report from Kislovodsk


Ahhh, Kislovodsk. Love this place. For those unaware, Kislovodsk is approximately 1,500kms SSE from Moscow located in the Stavropol Krai region (North Caucasus) located between the Black and Caspian Seas (each about 300kms away). The resident population of about 150,000 swells to well over 200,000 during the summer holiday period. ?

Temp ranges are acceptable at +25 to +30 during summer and down to a chilly 3 to -3 during winter.

Kislovodsk is mostly known for its extensive natural mineral spas and walking trails through the mountains and there are numerous resorts that specialize in wellness and relaxation. Russians have long regarded Kislovodsk, and the abundance of natural mineral water and clean mountain air, as having therapeutic value. Stressed oligarchs need somewhere to unwind! Prior to the Ukraine conflict, there was strong patronage from western Europeans but Iโ€™m told that has slowed to a trickle in the past year or so.

The Speedbox clan have relocated from Syktyvkar to catch up with numerous friends and a very small number of family. Beyond that, there is the impending renovation of our apartment and other real estate matters to action. I had hoped for something of a โ€˜holidayโ€™ but that hope diminishes as each day passes. We will be here for almost three weeks.

It is peak season now and I have never seen so many people, mostly families, on the streets. Cars and tourist buses are ever present and there is even โ€˜peak hourโ€™ traffic commencing around 5pm. It lasts for only 30 minutes but indicates the popularity of the city at this time.

As with Syktyvkar, the average age of the motor vehicles on the roads appears generally <5 years old. At a BBQ a few days ago I remarked to friends about recent media reports that Azerbaijan had recorded a 5000% (!) increase in Mercedes Benz imports. This caused great hilarity and others commented that not only Azerbaijan but Armenia, Georgia and Turkey are primary exporters for everything European into Russia. Cars are also coming from China in addition to a raft of other goods. Those are all in addition to the locally manufactured cars including from factories including those previously owned and operated by Renault and Nissan among others.

As mentioned in my report from Syktyvkar, the shops are full with extensive inventory of local and imported products. Again, the memo about sanctions didnโ€™t seem to get through to many international brands although in fairness, the products are nominally delivered to, say, Turkey. But the people at Colgate, Nestle, Apple, Nike et al, in addition to those at Mercedes Benz, Mazda, Toyota, BMW etc cannot be so dimwitted as to not recognise the sales spike of their product in countries neighboring Russia. Plausible deniability I imagine.

There is a lot of new building happening in Kislovodsk. New apartment blocks and commercial premises (particularly new shops) are springing up like mushrooms. New stand-alone houses are also under construction. Trucks carrying cement and building products seem to rumble past frequently. A good friend of ours is a real estate agent and she says that apartment prices are showing significant capital growth – especially at the upper end. Many properties are being sold to retirees from Moscow or St Petersburg (attracted by the health/wellness industry) or to investors from those same cities.

Similarly, our builder remarked that over the past three years, his apartment renovation business has never been busier. He simply doesnโ€™t have the time or the available work crew, to even think about undertaking new building construction.

Unlike Syktyvkar, bank interest rates for mortgages in Kislovodsk are a ghastly 20% for the purchase of existing property. New property attracts a still high 10%. Compared to Syktyvkar, the new property interest rate is double and +4 to 5% on existing property. This localized effort to contain the property boom is having little impact because, as our friend explained, by comparison to Moscow, Kislovodsk property prices are relatively cheap and many purchasers simply pay cash. For locals working in average jobs however, the interest rates are crushing.

The unemployment rate appears very low and like Syktyvkar, there is a distinct absence of homeless/drunks on the streets.

Overall, Kislovodsk is a thriving and comfortable resort city that seems unimpacted by the conflict in Ukraine.

On another note, the recent incursion by Ukraine forces into the Kursk region is a surprising development and it is not clear, to myself at least, what the strategic objective might have been.

Local reports of the size of the Ukrainian force vary โ€“ initially it was suggested about 1,000 men from a mechanized brigade with other reports suggesting up to 3,000 men. Whatever the size, local media is alive with reports (and video footage) of the Russian response including artillery, drones and infantry supported by devastating air strikes on Ukrainian columns by the Russian Air Force.

Which begs the question: โ€˜why?โ€™. There was not the faintest hope of holding the area against Russian forces. The idea that Ukraine forces could occupy a portion of Russian territory is preposterous. Therefore, what was the point? Local media report that the Russian military are engaged in intense fighting to encircle the Ukrainian force. Unless Iโ€™m mistaken, few Ukrainian soldiers will escape with their lives.

So, again I ask: why? To prove a point that Ukraine can send expeditionary forces into Russia? Ok, but if they are all killed it seems a foolish waste of scarce manpower. As a PR exercise? I wonder how that sits with the Ukrainian general public as yet more of their sons and husbands are returned in body bags from a futile battle that had no strategic objective. The number of young Ukrainian men killed or seriously wounded to date will already have an impact on Ukrainian demographics for the next decade.

Time will tell and the situation is still evolving but at first pass on the available information, this Ukrainian excursion into the Kursk region of Russia appears to a pointless waste of soldierโ€™s lives.

,

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

19 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
m0nty
m0nty
August 13, 2024 3:12 pm

The simple answer to why is that it puts Putin in a tough spot. Ukraine now claims to hold a thousand square km of Russian land, and is looking to expand the new northern front towards Belgorod in the northeast. You can choose to disbelieve the numbers, and fair enough too in the fog of war, but the Ukes have not been seriously driven back yet.

It has taken Putin a full week to organise a response, which would shift resources from the eastern front and test their supply lines. It will also test Russiaโ€™s internal military politics, as ambitious generals jockey for position without expending too many resources from their own little fiefdoms.

I suspect much of the reasoning involves the fact that recent materiel contributions from Europe and elsewhere have included a lot of offensive weaponry that is not as useful in defence, and they figured they would get better results attacking the lightly-guarded north than the well-set east.

As for whether Russia will swiftly retake its lost territoryโ€ฆ we have found in this war that defence is much easier than offence, given enough time to dig in. Now itโ€™s a choice for the Ukes to decide where they stop advancing and start fortifying.

another ian
another ian
August 13, 2024 3:33 pm

FWIW

“Ukraine Is Dying, It Hasnโ€™t Enough People Left To Thrive”

https://chiefio.wordpress.com/2024/08/10/ukraine-is-dying-it-hasnt-enough-people-left-to-thrive/

GreyRanga
GreyRanga
August 13, 2024 3:47 pm

I’d really like to go to Russia. A mates oldman went on the TransSiberian express from Vladivostok to Moskva early 70’s. Had a few problems along the way. He was buying Russian machinery of which the plant I was at brought. Very good quality, never had problems unlike some of the American stuff we got.

dover0beach
Admin
August 13, 2024 4:04 pm

Sorry, monty, but the Ukes are getting hammered there. Here are two better takes:

Armchair Warlord

@ArmchairW

ยท

5h

The only thing I’d want to add to Mikael’s excellent analysis here is that the Russians are actually fighting a much more conventional area defense than we’ve seen in the very static fighting in the Donbass.

They’re not trying to stop Ukrainian drives at the screen line like

Show more

Quote

Mikael Valtersson

@MikaelValterss1

ยท

9h

ANALYSIS: MAPPING IN FOG OF WAR, AUG 12th 2024

It’s much harder to be sure of frontlines during maneuver warfare and directly after a breakthrough, than during static attritional warfare. At the Kursk front we see it daily. I’ll try to explain how to be as sure as…

Time will tell, of course.

Cassie of Sydney
August 13, 2024 4:13 pm

Here’s a thought, why doesn’t m0nty head off to Ukraine and provide some military advice?

He’ll fit right in, they like Nazis in Ukraine.

m0nty
m0nty
August 13, 2024 5:31 pm

Sorry, monty, but the Ukes are getting hammered there.

As the second of those threads reminds us, this is not the time to be making sweeping statements like that given the impossibility of getting clean information this early in the battle. Armchair Warlord quotes it but then proceeds to wishcast his way to total victory.

Nobody but the generals knows anything close to the full picture, which is in flux anyway so no conclusions could be drawn at this stage even if you had perfect knowledge.

Muddy
Muddy
August 13, 2024 8:05 pm

I enjoying something different to read here. Please keep it up.

dover0beach
Admin
August 13, 2024 11:50 pm

monty, it’s far easier for the Russians to supply troops around Kursk because they are closer to Moscow than the Donbass and there are two large cities and therefore railheads available, as well as major roads.

This appears to have been a hail mary attempt to breakthrough and capture the Kursk NPP

Vicki
Vicki
August 14, 2024 2:50 pm

What a fascinating report. Thank you, Speedbox – you simply don’t often find this sort of accurate, first hand reporting of conditions inside of Russia in our media. You have to go looking for information on the internet – & most don’t do that.

As for the Ukrainian incursion into Russian territory – a desperate and cynical and cruel ploy by Zelensky to maintain western support. He knows it will likely incite an appropriate Russian response which may, in turn, restore funding and ammunition from the West.

Brislurker
Brislurker
August 15, 2024 8:59 am

I really enjoy your reports from your trips. They bring to us the reality we rarely hear or see about normal life in Russia.

GreyRanga
GreyRanga
August 16, 2024 7:07 am

The munted one has no idea of area. 1000 sq km? Just over 31 by 31 km.

GreyRanga
GreyRanga
August 16, 2024 7:08 am

He probably thinks thats just outside Moscow.

Makka
Makka
August 16, 2024 8:46 am

On another note, the recent incursion by Ukraine forces into the Kursk region is a surprising development and it is not clear, to myself at least, what the strategic objective might have been.

It’s for the vibe.

There’s an old Euro saying; Invading Russia is easy- getting out alive is the hard part.

Last edited 3 months ago by Makka
  1. Mark Levin today points out that it’s always Republican presidents that have their admin nominees blocked by Democrats, going back…

  2. I am amused. COP29 reaches groundbreaking trillion-dollar climate deal, but developing nations demand more (Sky News, 24 Nov) Following intense…

19
0
Oh, you think that, do you? Care to put it on record?x
()
x