Peace-Mongering, Ukraine style


News Reports and Analysis

Daily Mail, 30th November, 2021

The Daily Mail reported that three gatherings of some Downing Street staff had taken place during November and December of 2020. This was the lifting of the lid on the cesspool of cynicism that characterised the political response to Covid-19 all over the Western world, with the notable exception of Sweden.

In January and February of 2022, the lid was completely unseated. Up to twenty events involving Government staffers, most frequently Downing Street staffers, were investigated. These included two parties in Downing Street on the eve of the funeral of Prince Philip.

24th February, 2022

Russian commences “Special Military Operation” in Ukraine.

The White House 16th March, 2022

President Biden today announced an additional $800 million in security assistance to Ukraine, bringing the total U.S. security assistance committed to Ukraine to $1 billion in just the past week, and a total of $2 billion since the start of the Biden Administration.

Reuters, 30th March, 2022

In the most tangible sign yet of progress towards ending the war, Russia emerged from the talks promising to scale down military operations around Kyiv and the country’s north, and Ukraine proposed adopting a neutral status.

Wall Street Journal, 31st March, 2022

President Erdo?an announces that Turkey has hosted two rounds of Russian-Ukrainian peace talks. These talks had progressed to the point that Erdo?an offered to host a meeting between the two leaders. “Western officials have been hesitant to endorse Ukraine’s proposal to have its security guaranteed by outside powers…”

NPR 2nd April, 2022

“…around Kyiv and in northern Ukraine, Russian forces are withdrawing. …we don’t know yet where these Russian troops are going to be redirected to. The Pentagon says they aren’t going home…

“…there is an attack on a fuel depot in the Russian city of Belgorod, which is near the Ukrainian border.

“Russia has said that the attacks came from low-flying Ukrainian helicopters, but Ukraine’s top security officials deny it. … And Russia has said that this attack could also impact peace talks, which are ongoing.” [my emphasis]

Forbes 6th April, 2022

“A Pentagon official told reporters Wednesday all Russian troops had left the areas of Kyiv and Chernihiv to regroup and resupply in Belarus and Russia…”

BBC 9th April, 2022

‘Prime Minister Boris Johnson has held talks in Kyiv with Ukraine’s President Volodymyr Zelensky. No 10 said the visit was a “show of solidarity” with the Ukrainian people. Following the meeting, Downing Street said the UK would send 120 armoured vehicles and anti-ship missile systems to support Ukraine…

‘Mr Johnson paid tribute to “President Zelensky’s resolute leadership and the invincible heroism and courage of the Ukrainian people”, saying: “Ukraine has defied the odds and pushed back Russian forces from the gates of Kyiv“…[my emphasis] Speaking…alongside President Zelensky…Mr Johnson said Ukrainians “have shown the courage of a lion but you, Volodymyr, have given the roar of that lion”…

‘Mr Johnson’s visit to Kyiv came the day after the UK announced £100m of weapons for the country.’

12th April, 2022

Boris Johnson announces that he had received a Fixed Penalty Notice for violations of his own Government’s lockdown regulations.

New York Times 14th April, 2022

Biden Announces $800 Million in Military Assistance for Ukraine.

U.S. Department of Defense 21st April, 2022

President Joe Biden announced today that the United States will send another $800 million in equipment to help Ukraine defend itself against Russia’s two-month-long invasion. Today’s announcement comes on the heels of an $800 million military aid package the president signed last week.

7th July, 2022

Boris Johnson announces his intention to resign when the Conservative Party has selected a new leader.

6th September, 2022

Boris Johnson resigns the Prime Ministership.

New York Post 4th October, 2022

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky seemingly shut the door on the prospect of having any peace talks with Vladimir Putin — but not with Russia under a different leadership. Zelensky signed a decree on Tuesday formally declaring negotiations with the Kremlin autocrat to be “impossible.”

Vladimir Putin Astana press conference 14th October, 2022

“But we are also aware of Kiev’s position – they kept saying they wanted talks, and even sort of asked for them, but have now passed an official decision that bans such talks. Well, what is there to discuss?

“As you may be aware, speaking at the Kremlin when announcing the decision on the constituent entities of the Russian Federation, I said we are open. We have always said that we are open. We reached certain agreements in Istanbul, after all. These agreements were almost initialled. But as soon as our troops withdrew from Kiev, the Kiev authorities lost any interest in the talks. That is all there is to it.”

Foreign Affairs September/October 2022

Foreign Affairs is the house journal of the Council on Foreign Relations, the most influential foreign affairs think tank in the U.S. In the 2022 September/October was an article written by Fiona Hill and Angela Stent, titled The World Putin Wants: How Distortions About The Past Feed  Delusions About The Future. If you’re looking for a summary of every article written since February about Putin’s real motives and Putin’s real objectives in the “Special Military Operation” in Ukraine and Donbas, this is a good place to start.

Buried on page eleven is this passing acknowledgement, which is the most comprehensive description of the conditions for peace that had been agreed between Russian and Ukrainian negotiators 5 weeks after the commencement of the Russian “Special Military Operation”:

According to multiple former senior U.S. officials we spoke with, in April 2022, Russian and Ukrainian negotiators appeared to have tentatively agreed on the outlines of a negotiated interim settlement: Russia would withdraw to its position on February 23, when it controlled part of the Donbas region and all of Crimea, and in exchange, Ukraine would promise not to seek NATO membership and instead receive security guarantees from a number of countries.

Die Zeit 7th December, 2022

Angela Merkel’s interview with Die Zeit magazine is published. Merkel is tidying up her legacy. Among other things, she discusses her contradictory and poll-driven energy policies, including the shutdown of Germany’s nuclear industry, and her push, taken up personally with Vladimir Putin, for the building of Nord Stream 2. Most revealing though, in the current context, are her comments about policy towards Donbas, which require a little background.

After the US-engineered Maidan coup of 2014, which overthrew the elected government of Ukraine, the Russian-speaking Donetsk and Luhansk Oblasts – the Donbas – refused to recognise the newly installed government, and broke away. Ukrainian armed forces immediately occupied Donetsk airport and from there launched attacks on Donetsk city and surrounds. This led to very heavy and bitter fighting between the Ukrainian military and the separatist militias (with covert Russian support.) The first Minsk agreement, signed on the 14th of September, 2014, failed to stop the fighting. The second Minsk agreement, signed on the 12th of February, 2015, was more successful, but it was never fully implemented.

Now back to Merkel’s comments:

I thought the initiation of NATO accession for Ukraine and Georgia discussed in 2008 to be wrong. The contries neither had the necessary prerequisites for this, nor had the consequences of such a decision been fully considered, both with regard to Russia’s actions against Georgia and Ukraine and to NATO and its rules of assistance. And Minsk agreement was an attempt to give Ukraine time.

Ukraine used this time to get stronger, as you can see today. The Ukraine of 2014/15 is not the Ukraine of today. As you saw in the battle for Debaltsevo in early 2015, Putin could have easily overrun them at the time. And I very much doubt that the NATO countries could have done as much then as they do now to help Ukraine. [My emphasis.]

The Ukrainian defeat at Debaltsevo led to the signing of the second Minsk agreement. According to Merkel, it was “clear to all of us that the conflict was frozen, that the problem had not been solved, but that gave Ukraine valuable time.” Merkel also revealed that, in her view and presumably that of other Western leaders, “the Cold War never really ended because Russia was basically not at peace.” Another translation renders that as “…basically not satisfied.” NATO, she said “should have reacted more quickly to Russia’s aggressiveness” in 2014, contradicting her previous remarks. It was a long interview.

So Merkel, and no doubt her Western partners, cynically manipulated her interlocutors in the Minsk negotiations, but according to her, it was not Germany, the US and the UK that were “basically not satisfied” at the end of the Cold War, but Russia. Western powers never accept any opprobrium for cynical deceit and treachery, because the other side – in this case Russia – is always the underlying source of such destructive behaviour, and Merkel and Co are regrettably forced to respond in kind. Remember that Merkel was 35 in the year the Berlin Wall came down. She learned her trades in the world of The Lives of Others, but she found soul siblings in the foreign affairs organisations of the USA, the UK and the EU.

* * * *

All of the lives lost, the buildings and infrastructure destroyed, the refugees displaced, and the massive cost to the Ukrainian, Russian and Western economies since April flow from the sabotage of those peace talks. It is well to remember this now that negotiations are once again being proposed, this time by the USA, directly with Russia. The fact that these talks have been proposed by the US, and that Zelensky, who only a month ago declared that Ukraine would not negotiate with Russia until Putin was overthrown, turns the spotlight on the real real Western protagonist of this war. But that merely reasserts the lesson of Zelensky’s reneging on the April agreement.


Subscribe
Notify of
guest

17 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
billie
billie
December 10, 2022 8:43 am

Russia is unlikely to trust the west again as they are not honest negotiators.

From a position of strength and also the background financial system changes taking place, Russia does not need to negotiate.

USA overplayed this one and it might be fatal for NATO

Bruce of Newcastle
Bruce of Newcastle
December 10, 2022 10:25 am

The Great Game has been going on a long, long time. This is just the latest episode.

Much like the Italo-Greek War of 1940-41, which was between fascist Italy and fascist Greece. The Metaxas government was actually fairly close to Hitler, which didn’t prevent Mussolini from invading. Mussolini was recreating the Roman Empire, not unlike Putin’s hope to recreate Tsarist Russia at its height.

The Allies held their nose and supported Greece. Which helped Greece fight Mussolini to a standstill. He had to be rescued by Adolf, and that may’ve lost the war for the Axis since it delayed the launch of Barbarossa.

Geopolitics is only different now because of nuclear weapons, which cramp the style of egotistical leaders. We’ll always be plagued by egotists, it is a defining trait of the species homo politicus.

NFA
NFA
December 10, 2022 10:27 am

$38 billion dollar check for Ukraine on the horizon, thanks to RINOs
By Olivia Murray

As the new year approaches, I just have one question for the new beefed-up IRS: do I get to name Zelensky as a dependent when I file my taxes?

OldOzzie
OldOzzie
December 10, 2022 10:55 am

Congress Quietly Slips Ukraine Debt Relief into 4,400 Page National Defense Authorization Act

December 9, 2022 – Sundance

When it comes to congress and the graft that is Ukraine, nothing should come as a surprise.
Last month, the Biden administration asked Congress for another $37.7 billion in support for Ukraine. If that passes, and it certainly will, Congress will have approved more than $100 billion in Ukraine-related spending.

(Via Fox News) – The National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) for fiscal year 2023 passed the House Thursday afternoon in a 350-80 vote. Included in that 4,400-page bill is a section on “Ukraine Debt Payment Relief.”

That section says the U.S. treasury secretary will instruct U.S. representatives of international financial institutions to “use the voice, vote, and influence of the United States to advocate that the respective institution immediately provide appropriate debt service relief to Ukraine.”

It instructs Treasury to commence “immediate efforts” with other governments and commercial creditors to “pursue comprehensive debt payment relief for Ukraine.”

The language talks only about debt payment relief, and not forgiveness of the assistance given to Ukraine this year to defend itself from to Russia’s invasion.

OldOzzie
OldOzzie
December 10, 2022 10:57 am

Merkel’s ‘confession’ may be grounds for tribunal – Moscow

The former chancellor gave evidence that the West had orchestrated hostilities in Ukraine, the Russian Foreign Ministry says

A confession by former German chancellor Angela Merkel about the Minsk peace agreements could be used as evidence in a tribunal involving Western politicians responsible for provoking the Ukraine conflict between Moscow and Kiev, the Russian Foreign Ministry warned on Thursday.

The deal, brokered by Germany and France, was supposed to be a roadmap for peace in the war-torn country. Russian President Vladimir Putin has said that his country’s current military offensive was prompted by the failure to implement the terms of the accords.

The former German leader admitted in an interview with Die Zeit on Wednesday that the actual purpose of the Minsk agreements was to give Ukraine time to prepare for a military confrontation with Russia.

OldOzzie
OldOzzie
December 10, 2022 10:59 am

West using Ukrainians as ‘cannon fodder’ – Putin

The US and its “satellites” are using the country as a battering ram against Russia, the president insists

Western nations are intentionally seeding chaos and violence to achieve their geopolitical goals, Russian President Vladimir Putin has claimed. The conflict in Ukraine is an attempt by “the US and its satellites” to use the country to harm Russia, he stated.

Putin offered the disparaging analysis in a video address to defense ministers from several Asian nations who had assembled for a summit in Moscow.

“For years, the West has been brazenly draining and exploiting [Ukraine’s] resources, encouraged genocide and terror in Donbass, de-facto turned this nation into a colony, and is now cynically using the Ukrainian people as cannon fodder, a battering ram against Russia, as it keeps delivering weapons and munitions to Ukraine, sending mercenaries, pushing it down the path of suicide,” Putin said.

This violence is just one example of a destructive influence that Western nations exert around the world, in an attempt to preserve dominance on the global stage, the Russian president contended.

OldOzzie
OldOzzie
December 10, 2022 11:02 am

Putin responds to Merkel bombshell

The President believes that the former German leader’s remarks justified Moscow’s offensive in Ukraine

Russian President Vladimir Putin has said he is “disappointed” by former German chancellor Angela Merkel’s recent comments regarding the Minsk agreements – the now defunct roadmap for peace in Ukraine – which she admitted was a ruse to buy Ukraine more time to build up its military.

“What can you say to that?” Putin said during a press conference on Friday, adding that he was shocked to hear such a confession from the former German leader, having believed that Russia’s partners in Berlin “treated us with sincerity.”

The Russian leader said Merkel’s remarks once again prove that launching a military operation in Ukraine was the correct decision.

“As it turns out, nobody intended to fulfil any part of the Minsk agreements,” Putin said, recalling that former Ukrainian President Pyotr Poroshenko also recently admitted that he had no intention of adhering to the documents when he signed them in 2014 and 2015.

“I thought the other participants of this agreement were at least honest, but no, it turns out they were also lying to us and only wanted to pump Ukraine with weapons and get it prepared for a military conflict,” Putin said. “Apparently, we got our bearings too late, to be honest. Maybe we should have started all this [the military operation] earlier, but we just hoped that we would be able to solve it within the framework of the Minsk agreements.”

Vladimir Putin said Merkel’s admission raises an important question about trust. “Trust is already almost at zero, but after such statements, how can we possibly negotiate?

About what? Can we make any agreements with anybody and where are the guarantees?” Putin asked, while acknowledging that some sort of agreement will have to be reached eventually.

OldOzzie
OldOzzie
December 10, 2022 11:04 am

US sanctions Russia over Iranian droneshttps://www.rt.com/news/567981-us-sanctions-russia-iran-drones/

The Biden administration has accused Russian aerospace forces and the defense ministry of purchasing UAVs from Tehran

Meanwhile

Iran slams West over ‘uncontrolled’ arms shipments to Ukraine

Foreign minister warns that NATO-aligned states are fuelling the fighting

Wally Dalí
Wally Dalí
December 10, 2022 12:05 pm

Does the remembering-
?

Roger
Roger
December 10, 2022 1:34 pm

But that merely reasserts the lesson of Zelensky’s reneging on the April agreement.

Zelensky wasn’t authorised to agree to the terms being proposed, which would have included ceding Ukrainian territory to the Russians. The Ukrainian parliament wouldn’t have agreed, nor the general population. Not that I’m defending him, but we should have a clear grasp of the context before we start drawing moral lessons and apportioning blame.

Christine
Christine
December 10, 2022 5:59 pm

Roger 1.34pm
“before we start drawing moral lessons”
That’s right

What made the rat angry? I told him a story with a moral, said the linnet
Ah, always a dangerous thing to do, replied the duck

Botswana O'Hooligan
Botswana O’Hooligan
December 10, 2022 6:10 pm

The Australian Newspaper states that the USA OK’s Ukrainian drone strikes inside Russia so at last the white hats Vs black hats is out in the open, the USA hammering away at Russia as it has done since WW2, sometimes rightly so, many times unjustified. The bottom line as some of us who know the places is that the above continues but Ukraine will be but a vassal state of the USA for The Ukraine cannot possibly redeem it’s debt to the USA. Regarde the “lend lease” of WW2 when the USA so gallantly supplied the UK with arms and matériel for it took until the end of 2006 for the debt to be repaid by the UK.

dover0beach
Admin
December 10, 2022 8:45 pm

Zelensky wasn’t authorised to agree to the terms being proposed, which would have included ceding Ukrainian territory to the Russians. The Ukrainian parliament wouldn’t have agreed, nor the general population.

He can agree and then put the agreement to the Parliament, but given his extraordinary powers as HoS and CiC including the ban of main Opposition party, the control of the media, and the like, he has effective control to do as he pleases.

jupes
jupes
December 10, 2022 10:56 pm

Great analysis Peter. Thank you.

Bruce
Bruce
December 10, 2022 11:46 pm

Angular Murkel?

The old Stasi operative?

That Angular Murkel?

This caper has all the hallmarks of yet another “smoke and mirrors” operation.

Peter Colquhoun
Peter Colquhoun
December 11, 2022 3:39 pm

Reading this and some of the comments you might think it was Ukraine that invaded Russia, and not that unreconstructed Statlinist Putin that is responsible.

  1. FMD, Sal… it was barely good enough for a certain farmer’s wife with 4 kids in 1965, but it isn’t…

  2. If you leave Pablo in the can long enough it will stick to anything. I speak from experience.

  3. Miltonf May 25, 2024 2:00 pm It’s just shocking when you read that there are still people imprisoned without trial…

17
0
Oh, you think that, do you? Care to put it on record?x
()
x